Critical Review of the Pros and Cons of Using SYNDET vs Handmade Soap on Eczema

This article provides a comprehensive overview of the pros and cons of using SYNDET and handmade soap for eczema.

home

Critical Review of the Pros and Cons of Using SYNDET vs Handmade Soap on Eczema

Part 1:
1. Understanding SYNDET Soap
2. What is Eczema?
3. The Pros of SYNDET Soap for Eczema
4. The Cons of SYNDET Soap for Eczema
5. Recommendations for Choosing SYNDET Soap for Eczema
6. Conclusion 1
Part 2:
1. Handmade Soap for Eczema
2. Understanding Handmade Soap
3. The Pros of Handmade Soap for Eczema
4. The Cons of Handmade Soap for Eczema
5. Recommendations for Choosing Handmade Soap for Eczema
6. Overall Conclusion

PART 1: The Pros and Cons of Using Handmade Soap on Eczema

1.1 Understanding SYNDET Soap

SYNDET soap, short for synthetic detergent soap, differs from traditional soap in its composition. Traditional soaps are made through the saponification process, where fats or oils react with an alkali. In contrast, SYNDET bars are formulated using synthetic surfactants derived from petrochemicals or oleochemicals. These surfactants can be engineered to have specific properties, making SYNDET soap an appealing option for sensitive skin.

1.2 What is Eczema

Eczema, also known as atopic dermatitis, is a chronic skin condition characterised by red, itchy, and inflamed skin. Managing eczema involves various approaches, including the careful selection of skin care products. One type of soap often recommended for people with eczema is synthetic detergent (SYNDET) soap. This article explores the benefits and drawbacks of using SYNDET soap for eczema-prone skin.

1.3 The Pros of Using SYNDET Soap for Eczema

More Gentle on the Skin. SYNDET soaps are known for their mildness. Traditional soaps have a higher pH (typically between 9 and 10), which can disrupt the skin's natural acid mantle, leading to dryness and irritation id used too often. SYNDET bars have a pH closer to that of the skin (around 5.5), which helps maintain the skin's natural barrier function and reduces the risk of irritation.

Moisturising Properties. Many SYNDET soaps contain artificially added moisturising agents such as glycerin, ceramides, and emollients. These ingredients help simulate moisture, which is crucial for people with eczema, as their skin often lacks sufficient moisture. Regular use of moisturising SYNDET detergents can help reduce the dryness and flakiness associated with eczema.

Reduced Risk of Allergens. SYNDET soaps can be formulated to exclude common allergens and irritants. However, SYNDETS contain fragrances, dyes, and preservatives that can trigger eczema flare-ups. SYNDET bars, especially those labeled for sensitive skin, are often free from botanical irritants in some cases making them a safer choice for individuals with eczema.

Antibacterial Options. Some SYNDET soaps include antibacterial agents, which can help reduce the risk of skin infections. Eczema-prone skin is more susceptible to infections due to frequent scratching and thus skin dysfunction. Antibacterial SYNDET soaps can help keep the skin clean and reduce bacterial load, potentially preventing secondary infections just like a handmade soap.

Availability of Specialised Formulations. The versatility of SYNDET soaps allows for the creation of specialised formulations. For example, some SYNDET bars are designed to address specific skin conditions, including eczema. These formulations may include additional active ingredients like colloidal oatmeal, which has soothing and anti-inflammatory properties beneficial for eczema-prone skin.

1.4 The Cons of Using SYNDET Soap for Eczema

Potential for Irritation. While SYNDET soaps are generally milder than traditional soaps, they can still cause irritation in some individuals. Synthetic surfactants, particularly sulphates like sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), can be harsh on sensitive skin. It is important for individuals with eczema to choose sulfate-free SYNDET bars to minimise the risk of irritation.

Presence of Synthetic Chemicals. SYNDET soaps are made from synthetic chemicals, which can be a concern for those seeking natural or organic skincare products. Some individuals may prefer to avoid synthetic ingredients due to personal preferences or concerns about long-term exposure to synthetic chemicals.

Environmental Impact. The production of SYNDET soaps involves petrochemicals, which can have a negative impact on the environment. The extraction and processing of these chemicals contribute to pollution and resource depletion. Additionally, some synthetic surfactants are not biodegradable, leading to environmental concerns regarding water contamination and marine life.

Cost. SYNDET soaps can be more expensive than traditional soaps. The manufacturing process and the inclusion of artificial foamers, fragrances, detergents and ingredients often result in significantly higher production costs, which are passed on to consumers. For individuals with eczema who require frequent use of mild soap, the cost can add up over time.

Limited Availability of Certain Formulations. While there are many SYNDET soaps available on the market, finding a specific formulation that suits individual needs can be challenging. Some individuals may require a combination of specific ingredients to manage their eczema effectively. The availability of such specialised SYNDET formulations may be limited, making it difficult to find the perfect product.

1.5 Recommendations for Choosing SYNDET Soap for Eczema

Read Labels Carefully. When selecting a SYNDET soap for eczema, it is important to read the ingredient list carefully. Look for products labeled as hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, and sulfate-free. Avoid products with potential irritants, such as SLS and harsh preservatives.

Consult with a Dermatologist. Consulting with a dermatologist can provide valuable guidance in choosing the right SYNDET soap for eczema. Dermatologists can recommend specific products based on individual skin needs and sensitivities, ensuring a tailored approach to eczema management.

Patch Testing. Before using a new SYNDET soap on a large area of the body, perform a patch test. Apply a small amount of the product to a discreet area of skin and monitor for any adverse reactions over 24-48 hours. This can help identify potential irritants and prevent widespread reactions.

Consider Additional Skincare Practices. While using SYNDET soap can be beneficial, it should be part of a comprehensive skincare routine for eczema. Regular moisturising, avoiding known triggers, and using prescribed medications are essential components of effective eczema management.

1.6 Conclusion 1

This first part of the article provides a comprehensive overview of the pros and cons of using SYNDET over handmade soap for eczema, offering practical advice for individuals seeking to manage their skin condition. SYNDET soaps offer several possible advantages for individuals with eczema, including immediate (but not long-term) gentleness, moisturising properties under some circumstances, and reduced risk of organic but not artificial allergens. With a SYNDET for eczema, drawbacks such as the presence of synthetic chemicals, environmental impact, and cost should be considered. Choosing the right SYNDET soap involves careful consideration of individual skin needs, ingredient preferences, and consultation with a healthcare professional. By taking these factors into account, individuals with eczema can make informed decisions to help manage their condition effectively.

PART 2: The Pros and Cons of Using Handmade Soap on Eczema

2.1 Handmade Soap and Eczema

Another type of soap often recommended for people with eczema is handmade soap. This second part  explores the benefits and drawbacks of using handmade soap for eczema-prone skin.

2.2 Understanding Handmade Soap

Handmade soap is typically crafted using natural ingredients through a process called saponification, where fats or oils react with an alkali (usually sodium hydroxide) to form soap and glycerin. Unlike mass-produced commercial soaps, handmade soaps are often free from synthetic additives and can be customised with various beneficial ingredients.

2.3 The Pros of Using Handmade Soap for Eczema

Natural Ingredients. Handmade soaps are usually made with natural oils, butters, and essential oils. Ingredients such as olive oil, coconut oil, shea butter, and avocado oil are known for their moisturising and nourishing properties, which can be beneficial for eczema-prone skin. The absence of synthetic chemicals reduces the risk of irritation and allergic reactions.

Gentle Cleansing. Handmade soaps tend to be gentler on the skin compared to commercial soaps. They often have a balanced pH that is closer to the natural pH of the skin, which helps maintain the skin's acid mantle and barrier function. This gentle cleansing action can help reduce dryness and irritation in individuals with eczema.

Rich in Glycerin. The saponification process naturally produces glycerin, a humectant that attracts moisture to the skin. Handmade soaps retain this glycerin, unlike many commercial soaps where it is removed. The presence of glycerin helps keep the skin hydrated, which is crucial for managing eczema symptoms.

Customisable Formulations. One of the significant advantages of handmade soap is the ability to customise formulations to suit individual needs. For example, certain ingredients like colloidal oatmeal, honey, and aloe vera can be added for their soothing and anti-inflammatory properties. This customisation can provide targeted relief for eczema-prone skin.

Free from Harsh Chemicals. Handmade soaps are often free from synthetic fragrances, dyes, and preservatives, which are common irritants in commercial soaps. By avoiding these harsh chemicals, individuals with eczema can minimise the risk of flare-ups and skin reactions.

2.4 The Cons of Using Handmade Soap for Eczema

Variability in Quality. The quality of handmade soap can vary significantly depending on the ingredients used and the craftsmanship of the soap maker. Inconsistent quality can result in varying effectiveness and potential skin reactions. It is essential to choose reputable soap makers who use high-quality, skin-safe ingredients.

Potential Allergens. While handmade soaps are free from synthetic additives, they can still contain natural allergens. Essential oils, for example, can cause allergic reactions in some individuals. Patch testing a small area of skin before widespread use can help identify potential allergens and prevent adverse reactions.

Shorter Shelf Life. Handmade soaps typically have a shorter shelf life compared to commercial soaps due to the lack of synthetic preservatives. This shorter shelf life means the soap may need to be used more quickly to avoid spoilage. Proper storage, such as keeping the soap dry and away from direct sunlight, can help extend its usability.

Higher Cost. Handmade soaps can be more expensive than mass-produced commercial soaps. The use of high-quality, natural ingredients and the labor-intensive production process contribute to the higher cost. For individuals with eczema who require frequent use of mild soap, the cost can add up over time.

Limited Availability. While there is a growing market for handmade soaps, availability can still be limited compared to commercial soaps. Finding specific formulations that cater to individual needs may require purchasing from specialty stores or online vendors, which might not be as convenient as picking up a product from a local store.

2.5 Recommendations for Choosing Handmade Soap for Eczema

Research Ingredients. When selecting a handmade soap for eczema, it is crucial to research the ingredients used. Look for products that contain moisturising and soothing ingredients such as olive oil, shea butter, and colloidal oatmeal. Avoid products with potential allergens or irritants, even if they are natural.

Consult with a Dermatologist. Consulting with a dermatologist can provide valuable guidance in choosing the right handmade soap for eczema. Dermatologists can recommend specific ingredients to look for or avoid based on individual skin sensitivities and needs.

Patch Testing. Before using a new handmade soap on a large area of the body, perform a patch test. Apply a small amount of the product to a discreet area of skin and monitor for any adverse reactions over 24-48 hours. This can help identify potential irritants and prevent widespread reactions.

Read Reviews and Recommendations. Reading reviews and seeking recommendations from other individuals with eczema can provide insights into the effectiveness of specific handmade soap brands and formulations. Online forums and support groups can be valuable resources for finding products that have worked well for others with similar skin concerns.

2.6 Overall Conclusion 2

,This second part of the article provides a comprehensive overview of the pros and cons of using handmade soap for eczema, offering practical advice for people looking to manage their skin condition. Handmade soaps offer several advantages for individuals with eczema, including the use of natural ingredients, gentle cleansing, and customisable formulations. However, potential drawbacks such as variability in quality, potential organic based allergens (usually nuts and flowers in undisclosed ingredient labels), shorter shelf life, higher cost, and limited availability should be considered.

Choosing the right handmade soap involves consideration of individual skin needs, ingredient preferences, and consultation with a healthcare professional. By taking these factors into account, individuals with eczema can make informed decisions regarding their skin condition. When choosing a soap for managing eczema bear in mind the pros and the cons of using a SYNDET (a normal supermarket soap) or a handmade soap. Considering the points reported in Part 1 of this article's conclusion, SYNDETs are on the whole more of a risk in managing eczema. Handmade soap also involves risks, but less of them. On the whole artificial chemicals tend to make eczema worse and natural ingredients tend to result in a more favourable outcome in the long-term management of eczema.

home